Skip to main content

A deep dive into shark conservation

Misinformation about sharks could lead to population declines, disrupting ecosystems

shark conservation discussion
March 13, 2020

“Baby Shark,” the viral children’s song that became the postseason anthem of the Washington Nationals, may be unforgettable, but it’s also inaccurate. Despite what the catchy music video suggests, female sharks are often larger than male sharks, according to Arizona State University postdoctoral researcher and marine conservation biologist David Shiffman. And the cute animation is symptomatic of a broader cultural problem: People do not know very much about sharks.

On March 5, Shiffman spoke to a group of scientists, environmentalists and science communicators at ASU’s Barbara Barrett and Sandra Day O’Connor Washington Center about why sharks are in trouble and how misinformation, particularly online, impacts the species. According to the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s Red List of Threatened Species, 24% of sharks and their relatives are threatened by extinction. Shiffman cautions that humans are better off with healthy shark populations since declines disrupt ecosystems.

Though Shiffman’s research initially focused on policy solutions designed to protect sharks, he quickly found that there were broader problems that needed to be addressed first.

“When I start talking about what the experts think is the best thing to do, I encounter a lot of very passionate and enthusiastic nonexperts who not only don’t know that stuff, but actively don’t believe it,” Shiffman said. “So my research has shifted in recent years to, ‘Why do so many people believe wrong things about sharks and shark conservation, and how does that influence policy outcomes?’”

Shark conservation is surprisingly complex, and sharks face multiple threats to their survival, including threats from humans. Shiffman emphasized that, although unsustainable overfishing is one of the main threats that sharks face today, it is not the only threat conservationists and advocates must address.

A major obstacle to conservation efforts is the spread of misinformation, which makes it challenging to have rational, fact-based conversations about shark conservation, and to convince the public and policymakers that sharks should be protected.

For instance, there are activists who have been calling for a ban on shark fisheries because they don’t believe sustainable fishery exists. Shiffman argues there are plenty of fisheries in the U.S. and around the world that are sustainable.

“People who have no idea what they’re talking about are given huge platforms, and the rise of social media has been really bad for the spread of pseudoscientific nonsense,” Shiffman said. “One way we can protect sharks is by learning the real facts and not spreading misinformation.”

Shiffman’s lecture was sponsored by ASU’s Consortium for Science, Policy and Outcomes and was part of an ongoing series of policy seminar breakfasts.

Top photo by Hager Sharp

More Science and technology


Graphic depiction of a membrane ion channel.

Chilling discovery: Cold-sensing protein may pave the way for safer pain relief

For millions of people worldwide who live with chronic pain, the only treatments currently available often rely on opioids, which carry the risks of addiction and overdose. However, new research…

Person in a white lab coat and blue gloves handling lab equipment to research stem cell technology.

Harnessing benefits of stem cells for heart regeneration

Mehdi Nikkhah, an associate professor of biomedical engineering in the Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering at Arizona State University, and his collaborators at Mayo Clinic in Arizona have been…

Students seated at desks in a classroom listen to an unseen speaker.

Newly accredited ASU summer program opens up STEM opportunities for underrepresented students

It was Monday afternoon. Spotify was playing pop music in the background and the instructor stood behind a lectern wearing a paper Burger King crown. It is not a scene one would expect in a college…