Skip to main content

Former CIA director addresses political discourse in America

Several phenomena are driving populist movements in the world, says John Brennan at annual ASU Rhodes lecture

man speaking at podium
February 28, 2019

Former CIA director John Brennan warned that the complexities of modern-day governing are causing leaders around the world to hold so tightly onto power that they risk becoming demagogues.

“The leaders are trying to protect themselves and their base; they’re delegitimizing the press, and they’re trying to undermine the independence of the judiciary, and that’s authoritarian,” Brennan said.

Brennan, who served as director of the Central Intelligence Agency from 2013 to 2017, addressed a crowd at the Tempe Center for the Arts on Thursday night. His talk, titled “The State of Political Discourse in America,” was the annual John J. Rhodes Lecture in Public Policy, presented by Barrett, The Honors College at Arizona State University. 

“As the challenges of governing in the 21st century become more complex, they’re stifling opposition, they’re playing on the fears of people — about people who are coming across the border — and they’re offering simple solutions, like reviving an industry that’s no longer relevant in a modern economy.”

Brennan said that several phenomena are driving populist movements in the world, including globalization, the digital domain and disparity in wealth.

“This disparity of wealth and opportunity really is a concern and is something that is motivating a lot of people to say, ‘What about me?’,” he said.

“In addition, you have increased migration, and you have people who don’t fit a national identity. That’s why the populist movement is being fueled by this sentiment and this tug of war between the beneficiaries of globalization and those who feel victimized.”

Brennan cited Brexit as an example.

“A lot of people in rural areas said, ‘We need to go back to the good old days,’” he said.

“All the major cities and the youth voted to remain in the European Union and recognized that it’s impossible to extricate themselves from the global environment.”

Brennan said that politicians who put loyalty to party, or campaign donors, or personal gain above their responsibilities to their constitution do a disservice to the nation.

“They also send a disturbing signal to the next generation of leaders about who we are as Americans,” he said.

“They should be held accountable.”

Brennan never mentioned President Donald Trump by name but he said that he will continue to be critical of elected leaders “who do not uphold those standards of decency.” Brennan’s security clearance was pulled last year after he harshly criticized Trump.

The lecture is named for John J. Rhodes, who represented Arizona in the House of Representatives from 1952 to 1982. Brennan said that Rhodes understood bipartisanship.

“John Rhodes was an example of a politician who was able to reach across the aisle on so many issues, like energy and education and the federal budget,” Brennan said.

“He was an example of the ability to work with those who have a different perspective than you.”

Earlier on Thursday, Brennan met with Barrett students.

“I’m impressed with the intellectual curiosity of the students I meet, and I always encourage them to consider public service,” said Brennan, who joined the CIA in 1980.

“I tell them to think about what they’ll do to make this country better. The rewards are priceless, and you know you’re part of something larger than yourself.”

Top photo: Former CIA Director John Brennan delivers the 2019 John J. Rhodes Lecture on Feb. 28, 2019, at the Tempe Center for the Arts. He spoke to nearly 600 people about the current state of the political dissonance. Photo by Charlie Leight/ASU Now

More Law, journalism and politics


Woman talking with two student journalists in office

ASU's Carnegie-Knight News21 wins RFK Journalism Award for 'America After Roe'

The Carnegie-Knight News21 program has been honored with two Robert F. Kennedy Journalism Awards — including the prestigious 2024 Grand Prize, an honor not typically bestowed on college journalists…

Students sitting on outdoor tables in courtyard in downtown Phoenix

ASU Law, Diné College, Navajo Nation partner on first-ever tribally affiliated legal program

In a historic move in the advancement of legal education, the Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law at Arizona State University has announced a groundbreaking set of partnerships with the Navajo Nation…

Headshot of Angela Hill.

Winning the ultimate prize

When Angela Hill left a good-paying job in marketing for a shot at journalism, all she wanted to do was tell stories, inform people and make a difference. And she did exactly that. Her work for ABC…