Skip to main content

ASU series on tough health conversations begins with talk on taking away the keys

Mayo Clinic professor offers guidance on what loved ones can do when health condition makes it unsafe for patient to drive

Joseph Drazkowski speaking at event
October 17, 2017

Driving is one of those privileges we all take for granted until we can’t do it anymore. We drive to get to work (some of us drive for work), we drive to meet with friends, we drive to get food — we drive to complete any number of mundane, everyday tasks that require us to get from point A to point B.

As one of Joseph Sirven’s patients told him, “Driving is life.”

Sirven, a faculty memberSirven is also a professor of neurology at Mayo Clinic School of Medicine and an adjunct faculty member of the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at ASU. of Arizona State University’s School for the Science of Health Care Delivery, told the anecdote to a crowd gathered Tuesday night at the Downtown Phoenix campus as he introduced the first of six talks to be hosted by the school over the coming academic year: “We Need to Talk: A Series of Tough Conversations About Health.”

The series brings in experts to discuss the medical, ethical and legal issues surrounding hot-button health topics such as artificial medical devices, end-of-life care decisions and medical mistakes.

The topic of Tuesday’s discussion was “Can I Drive? Taking Away the Keys: Legal & Medical Quandaries.” Joseph Drazkowski — associate dean and professor of neurology at Mayo Clinic School of Medicine — was the guest speaker, with CBS 5 TV morning anchor Preston Phillips, ASU Professor of Practice at the Hugh Downs School of Human Communication Pauline Davies and KJZZ Radio senior field correspondent Carrie Jung moderating.

A self-described “motorhead,” Drazkowski said that as a neurologist, driving is something that impacts his patients — who have disorders ranging from epilepsy to dementia — a lot. Throughout the discussion, he covered such questions as: What are the appropriate medical and legal approaches to pulling someone’s keys? When can they not drive, and what is the medical community’s ethical responsibility? And if self-driving cars become accepted, will these issues go away?

As a practicing physician in the state of Arizona, Drazkowski is not required by law to report patients whose conditions may inhibit their ability to drive to the MVD (some states, like Nevada, do). Arizona is a “self-report” state, meaning patients with such conditions are responsible for informing the MVD themselves. It can be problematic, especially since giving up the ability to drive is like giving up one’s independence, Drazkowski said.

When that’s the case, there are options. Friends and family members can send a letter of concern to the MVD, which has a medical review department and can take steps to require the driver in question to take a driving test or undergo medical evaluation. Depending on how that goes, Drazkowski said, it may be time to sit down and have an honest discussion with the driver.

“Express your concerns and be realistic,” he said. “No two situations are alike. It’s a delicate, delicate balance.”

For people with dementia, who may not even remember why they aren’t allowed to drive, physically removing the car from the home and making other arrangements may be necessary. Luckily, ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft now have options where those in need of a ride can get one without having to use a smartphone.

It’s a start, but Drazkowski is most excited for the next step after that: fully autonomous vehicles. Once that hurdle has been cleared, he said, he believes it will truly solve the issue of driving for anyone with a condition that might prohibit them from doing so.

“And it would be easier for practitioners,” he said, “because we could say, ‘Here’s your alternative.’ ”

In response to Davies’ question of whether he plans to use an autonomous car to get around when the time comes, Drazkowski seemed enthused.

“I’ll soup up that autonomous driving vehicle,” he said.

More Health and medicine


Man loading box of food into car

ASU professors contribute to special issue on pandemic's impact on Latino families

Three Arizona State University professors co-authored five of 10 articles in a special issue of the Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology that examined the impact of the COVID-19…

ASU's Health North Building is seen in the foreground with Downtown Phoenix in the background on a sunny day.

ASU alum using degree to provide care for Arizona's underserved communities

By Max Baker Born and raised in Alaska, Davina Vea knows what it’s like to go without. The Arizona State University alumna was isolated not just geographically, but from family as well. Her parents…

abstract image of vital sign indicator line with a heart between two hands

Does low testosterone lead to heart disease?

Is low testosterone a contributor to cardiovascular disease? Is testosterone replacement the answer? It's a bit more complicated than that, according to researcher Ben Trumble, whose study of the…