It's a student challenge based on a real-world scenario: A crippling cyberattack has hit the United States. You and your team must develop a response that includes identifying potential damage to public and private sector interests. You must come up with a plan to deal with possible public backlash and consequences to international diplomacy. And you must adapt your response in real time as new information becomes available.

Think you're up to the task? ASU is looking for students to compete in a qualifyng round to advance to the 2017 Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge in Washington, D.C. this spring. The deadline to apply is Dec. 15.  The ASU team of Marcel Lambert, Justin Tran, Sarah Galvin and Connor Smith at the 2016 Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge. Download Full Image

"Cybersecurity is our most critical policy challenge in the 21st Century,” said retired U.S. Army Col. Bruce Pagel, a professor of practice in the College of Public Service and Community Solutions in downtown Phoenix. “It profoundly impacts national security, personal privacy, the media, and the global economy.”  

Last year's competition drew 40 teams from 25 universities. Justin Tran, Sarah Galvin, Marcel Lambert, and Connor Smith represented ASU. 

"The world is changing and rapidly becoming more digital," said Justin Tran, a political science major. "I believe the Atlantic Council's Cyber Challenge is one of the best ways to prepare young students for the future we will live in and protect American lives and interests as we move further and further into the 21st century."

Tran heard about the competition from a class he was taking but wasn't sure it was for him. Then, a classmate who competed the previous year convinced him how significant this opportunity was.

Justin Tran, Sarah Galvin, Marcel Lambert and Connor Smith represented Arizona State University in the 2016 Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge in Washington, D.C.

"The Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge was an absolutely incredible experience for me," Sarah Galvin said. "As an undergraduate engineering student working to adopt a concurrent degree in political science I cannot imagine a better opportunity to interact with people who are driving the effort to ensure American cybersecurity and defense."

The competition tasks students with responding to the security, political and economic problems caused by an evolving state-sponsored cyberattack scenario. They are required to write a policy brief, present their findings to a panel of judges and answer questions from judges.

"Cyber 9/12 provides a unique opportunity for students to go deep into the intersection of cyber policy and technology, and test their thinking and writing skills against those of their peers — skills that will undoubtably help them succeed in the workplace," said Pagel, who coaches the ASU team.

The 2016 competition was based on a scenario in which a US defense contractor's computer systerms were hacked. Highly sensitive data was compromised including possible control of GPS satellites. The cyberattack meant that communication with figher jets and commercial aircraft were at risk as was cellular phone communication. In the commotion, nuclear-armed rivals India and Pakistan are brought to the brink of war after one country shoots down a commercial aircraft of the other that strayed into its airspace. 

Tran said having a basic understanding of foreign affairs is preferable for the challenge. The one quality that will benefit students the most, Tran said, is enthusiasm.

"I truly think that anyone who is passionate and willing to put in time and effort into researching issues is capable of competing and doing well," Tran said.

The ASU team that competed in the 2016 competition presented a comprehensive policy response that addressed the multifaceted nature of cyber threats. Team members recommended a course of action that included security measures, diplomacy and public outreach. The plan sought cooperation from both the public and private sectors.

The ASU team's policy and technical experience were recognized by several judges to be among the most impressive of all the teams present. ASU was one of only two public universities to make it to the semifinal round.

"By all accounts, our team exceeded even our own expectations and performed well under pressure," Tran said. "I could not be prouder of our accomplishments and achievements."

The competition is sponsored by the Atlantic Council, a Washington, D.C. based think tank that focuses on political, economic and security issues affecting the Americas, Europe and Asia. The Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge is named for what policymakers would do the day after a crisis such as 9/11.  The event offers students the chance to meet and learn from respected leaders on security issues in the public and private sector in Washington, D.C. This year's event featured live hacking demonstrations and panel discussions that focused on careers.

The Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge allows students to network with competitors, judges and experts from the public and private sector.

“The Cyber 9/12 Student Challenge provides a valuable opportunity to network with highly regarded cyber experts in both the academic community and the private sector, including access to cyber career information and discussions with potential employers," Pagel said. "The luncheon speakers, sidebar panel discussions, along with the competition itself, all provide an enriching and not-to-be missed student experience."           

Justin Tran wants to enter next year's competition, but a heavy class load for the spring semester may prevent him from registering. For other students wondering whether to sign up, Tran says the experience is worth it.

"This competition was a truly enriching experience and a rare opportunity to not only learn from leaders in their fields but to network and challenge ourselves in the most intellectually stimulating manner possible," Tran said.

The cyber challenge is open to students currently enrolled in an undergraduate, graduate, doctoral, professional, or law program. No specific major, coursework or experience in cyber conflict is necessary, but successful applicants usually have a strong link between cyber conflict policy and their current academic interest.

Teams will be made up of four students, but consideration may be given to teams of three people. A qualifying round will be held to determine who will represent ASU at the Washington, D.C. competition. Students who are interested in competing in the 2017 Cyber 9/12 Challenge have until Thursday, Dec. 15 to apply. More information is available here.

Lisa Baer had little hesitation making the decision her freshman year to major in computer science.

Now, looking forward to graduating from Arizona State University in the spring, Baer said she has never second-guessed her choice. In fact, she is “more passionate than ever” in pursuit of a career as a computer scientist. Carole-Jeane Wu (standing in center), an assistant professor of computer science in ASU's Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering, says more diversity in her field will enable it to better serve society's varying needs. Photo by Peter Zrioka/ASU Download Full Image

But despite the confidence she gained in her abilities in the field during the past four years, she wasn’t completely immune to what psychologists call the “impostor syndrome.”

“It’s that feeling you get that your accomplishments aren’t due to your own merits, and fearing that one day you will be exposed and disappoint people,” she said.

She wasn't alone among her fellow female computer science students in experiencing such feelings.

Studies say the syndrome seems to be common even among high-achievers, particularly women who find themselves in situations where they can feel out of place or isolated because of their gender.

That describes the kind of environment found in many computer science college classrooms and labs, where women remain a disproportionately small minority.

“You might think that being the only woman in a class would make you feel special. But it really doesn’t,” said Nichola Lubold, who earned an undergraduate degree in computer engineering and is now working on a doctoral degree in computer science.

“I’ve never felt that I’m not good enough,” she said. “But you can still get this feeling that maybe I don’t belong and maybe this isn’t right for me.” 

Connecting with peers, mentors and role models

Carole-Jean Wu, an assistant professor of computer science in ASU’s Ira A. Fulton Schools of Engineering, said she sees that kind of doubt prevalent among some of the female students who make up only 15 percent of the 1,900-plus computer science majors at the university.

As a result, “we have really bright students who don’t stay” in the program, Wu said.

She points out that in addition to a small percentage of peers among female computer science majors, the number of female faculty members in the program is also comparatively low.

“So those students don’t see a lot of role models, and some of them don’t see a friendly environment or a good future for themselves in the field,” she said.

To try to change that situation, Wu and some of her faculty colleagues have worked to establish and maintain support for a scholarship program to send many of the women in the Fulton Schools computer science program to the annual Grace Hopper Celebration of Women in Computing.

The event produced by the Anita Borg Institute for Women in Technology and presented in partnership with the Association for Computing Machinery is the world’s largest technical conference for women in computing, drawing more than 15,000 participants from more than 60 countries.

With a grant from the Anita Borg Institute’s Building, Recruiting and Inclusion for Diversity (BRAID) initiative, and additional support from one of the Fulton Schools — the School of Computing, Informatics, and Decision Systems Engineering— and ASU’s Global Security Initiative, 50 of ASU’s female computer science students were able to earn scholarships to make the trip to Houston for the 2016 Grace Hopper conference in October.

At least 10 other ASU students also attended — some with support from companies for which they are working as interns.

A scholarship program started by faculty members has enabled many women majoring in computer science at ASU to attend the annual Grace Hopper Celebration of Women in Computing. The conference enables students connect to a community of mentors, peers, role models and potential employers in the computer science field. Pictured are some of the more than 50 ASU students who attended this year’s conference. Photo by Faye Navabi/ASU

Feeling a sense of community

The event features leaders in the field from industry, academia and government, presentations on research, opportunities for networking and mentoring, and a career fair for those seeking jobs and student internships.

In addition, there are professional development sessions geared to address the particular concerns of women working in the high-tech world.

Students get chances to see and learn about women who are making significant contributions to computing, and to seek out professional relationships that could nurture them throughout their careers, Wu said.

“It’s a good place to meet people in various stages of their careers, especially women who are dealing with career, family and life challenges at different times in their lives,” she said. “Students can learn from people who have successfully dealt with these issues.”

Baer said it’s invaluable for students because “you feel a sense of community, like you can be part of something important and make a real difference.”

Lubold, who wants to have children while still building her career, said the conference has given her the opportunity to “hear from women who have been where I am in my career and to learn from their experience.”

Learning about overcoming obstacles

Nichole Emmons, who is graduating with a bachelor's degree in December, calls the conference a “really powerful” experience.

“It’s amazing to see how it impacts the younger students, the ones you can tell are having those thoughts about wondering whether they want to be in a male-dominated field,” she said. “[The conference] gives them a new perspective and people they can relate to. You can see that it is going to change them.”

Waverly Roeger, who will receive her bachelor's degree in the spring, was once one of those students.

Talking and listening to others who had coped with feelings of being outsiders within their field of study “made me feel that I did belong, and that was a huge weight lifted off me,” she said.

The conference also helped her to see that the challenges she was facing were not a sign of a lack of ability.

“You learn about the obstacles these women overcame, and that their success didn’t happen because they are geniuses,” Roeger said. “You see that it took them years of hard work to build up what they have.”

Inclusiveness brings benefits to the field

The students are emphatic that their profession will contribute more to society if its practitioners are more diverse.

“When you bring different kinds of people to the table, there is a wellspring of creativity,” Lubold said. “We will come up with new technologies and solutions adapted to the different needs of a wider range of people.”

Emmons said that if only a select group of people are involved in making and using new technologies, “then a lot of people are just going to be left out” of the future that technologists are creating.

The Grace Hopper conference “is inspiring and motivating,” Roeger said, “but you also see there is a lot that still has to be done to bring awareness about the importance of diversity. And it’s not just about gender but across the spectrum of ethnicity and culture and people of color, LGBTQ people, and people with varying abilities and disabilities.”

Wu, who directs the Fulton Schools’ Energy-Efficient Computer Architecture Lab, said diversity improves the quality of research.

“It brings different perspectives to how we approach solving problems and to our decisions about what problems are most important to solve,” she said.

Women needed to meet labor demand

Nadya Bliss, director of ASU’s Global Security Initiative, is especially concerned about the lack of women earning degrees in computer science. Fewer than one out of five undergraduate degrees in computer science and engineering go to women, according to some studies.

Nadya Bliss

Bliss said the field is becoming more essential to the pursuit of advances “in every kind of security challenge we have,” including national defense, climate security and health security.

More than that, computer science is more integral to everything from biology, business and medicine to agriculture, manufacturing, construction, journalism and social sciences, she said.

She sees the need for computer science expertise growing so rapidly that demand will significantly exceed supply, and that without more women in the field the labor pool will be depleted.

“We’re looking at maybe a million unfilled jobs,” she said. “So it’s important that schools as big as the Fulton Schools and ASU take on the challenge of helping to solve this problem.”

Much of the problem stems from “culturally ingrained attitudes” about women in science, and in computer science in particular, which are causing women to choose not to pursue those careers, she said.

Many female high school and even college students who are interested in science, engineering and other technical fields often “look around their classrooms and don’t see anyone who looks like them,” she said.

Evolving beyond stereotypes

Bliss, who spent a decade in leadership roles at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory, a Department of Defense Research and Development Laboratory, said she was fortunate to grow up in a family with a tradition of women in highly skilled technical jobs.

Her mother is an engineer, one grandmother led a company’s technology division and the other grandmother was a neurologist.

As a computer science undergraduate at Cornell University, she was usually one of only a handful of women in her classes, but she had male mentors to whom “gender didn’t matter,” she said. “They just saw me as a smart student who they should help to advance. I never questioned whether I should be there.”

The work environment at MIT Lincoln Laboratory was similarly supportive.

“If you were into math, it didn’t mean you could not be into dresses. There wasn’t that image of ‘real scientists don’t wear dresses.’ The culture was one of technical meritocracy,” she said.

Unfortunately, the stereotypes still have a widespread negative impact.

“It’s not good to have a culture that is not friendly to diversity, not friendly to things like people with families also having careers,” Bliss said.

Until only a few years ago, she was not compelled to talk much about the subject. She recalls telling those who asked her to speak out that she saw herself “as a computer scientist, not as a woman computer scientist, and I didn’t want to move out of my scientist role and into the role of the woman talking about these touchy issues.”

Now she realizes, “It’s better for everyone if we just talk about this and deal with it. We need to break out of the stereotype mold, and I’m at a point in my career where I want to do everything I can to keep women from quitting the field because of that.”

Making diversity a priority

Wu points out that in addition to strong support from Bliss, other ASU colleagues in the computer science program have been putting extra effort into aiding that cause.

Wu worked with senior lecturer Faye Navabi to develop the scholarship program that has sent hundreds of students to the Grace Hopper conference over the past three years. Navabi and Principal Lecturer Mutsumi Nakamura oversee a Women in Computer Science student club.

Assistant Professor Sharon Hsiao and Lecturer Kanika Grover are on the scholarship program’s organization committee. Grover and Navabi went to this year’s Grace Hopper event as mentors to the ASU students who attended.

Professor Ronald Askin, the former director of the School for Computing, Informatics, and Decision Systems Engineering, has supported the scholarship program from its inception.

He helped to raise funds to establish the scholarship and then continued to participate in activities to raise awareness of the need for women in the field, Wu said.

Askin has been joined in his support by the school's interim director, professor Sandeep Gupta.

“They have all been going above and beyond the call of duty to make this an important goal,” Wu said.