image title

The complex lives of leaf cutter ants

February 21, 2020

ASU alumna is looking at how climate change could affect the ants' foraging habits

We don’t always think about the insect world buzzing below our feet. But the health of those tiny, complex societies gives us important clues about the health of the planet at large. 

In research published this week, Arizona State University alumna Lauren Welch examines how the foraging habits of leaf cutter ants could change with global warming, and what that means for humans. 

Leaf cutters are a tropical species appearing in South and Central America, and parts of the American South. Welch first came across the species while on a study abroad program to the Panamanian rainforest through the School of Life Sciences in The College of Liberal Arts and Sciences. 

Launched in 2014 through a partnership between ASU and the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, each summer Experimental Tropical Biology gathers around 12 students to spend two to three weeks doing a field study of their choice. Welch went during the summer of 2018 and remembers noticing leaf cutter ants right away.

“Leaf cutters stuck out to me in Panama because they're just very ubiquitous, whether you're near the school grounds where we stayed, or deep into the actual rainforest, they’re always there,” said Welch, who graduated with a bachelor’s degree in biological sciences in 2019.

Lauren Welch

School of Life Sciences alumna Lauren Welch recently published research examining how the foraging habits of leaf cutter ants could change with global warming.

The heat factor

Using a pair of powerful, scissorlike mandibles, leaf cutters tear pieces of leaves and other foliage and haul the load back to underground colonies. As the material decays, the ants break it down to harvest a fuzzy white, nutrient-rich fungus used to feed their offspring.

In Panama, Welch began to wonder how factors like heat and sunshine affected this process. 

“By counting both the number of ants coming in and the leaves they were carrying, we wanted to understand the temperature and time of day they were most successful,” Welch said.

Her findings, which now appear in the peer-reviewed journal Insectes Sociaux, suggest leaf cutters active during Panama’s rainy season from May until December increase foraging speed and success as the day gets progressively warmer, thus reaching peak leaf intake during midday.

“Being there during the rainy season meant even midday temperatures were moderate, so midday was when we were hitting what turned out to be a great temperature for the ants because it wasn’t so hot they had to stay inside, but just warm enough to increase their productivity.” 

Insect impact

Some might wonder why something like leaf cutter foraging should matter in the human world. Welch said understanding these patterns could help us plan for the future, especially as global temperatures continue to climb due to climate change. 

“First of all, these ants are social insects, so understanding their patterns could help us better understand other social insects like bees,” she said. “Plus, the leaf cutter variety I studied, Atta colombica, is considered a pest species because their mass foraging causes problems for crops. If they are going to be even more productive in the heat, we need to start thinking about what that means for farmers, forests and other ecosystems.”

Kaitlin Baudier is a postdoctoral researcher in the School of Life Sciences who co-instructed Welch’s summer session and co-authored her research in Insectes Sociaux. She said leaf cutters play a complicated role in the overall health of tropical ecosystems. Tracking their progress could serve as a marker for what’s to come for the greater natural world. 

“Leaf cutters are often called ecosystem engineers because they make these tremendously huge colonies and circulate a lot of soil. But they also defoliate a lot of plants and cause problems for farmers and loggers,” she said. “They can be used as a social model for thinking about the complex social ramifications of big temperature changes — in an ecological sense, they are an important keystone without which things are surely going to change.”

Baudier said Welch’s data suggests warmer temperatures will benefit the ants in the short term, but that could change as heat rises more severely during Panama’s warmer dry season.

“We found that with warming temperatures there might actually be an increase in productivity in the cooler times of day and cooler times of year because temperatures are going to be warmer but not too warm,” she said, “But in the warmer times of year, their foraging speed may already be maxing out and thus potentially even be worse by midday.”

Research already exists on leaf cutter habits, but Welch’s work adds valuable field data that might otherwise not be observed in a lab.

“Existing literature suggests this species chooses to forage at different times of day depending on the season, but Lauren’s research asks whether light and temperature each play a role in that process as well,”she said. “She measured how well they forage, intake food and run in relation to the environmental temperature. That's important especially because she was able to get all these data collections right in the field with naturally-occuring colonies.”

Student research

Researchers from the School of Life Sciences

From left: Jon Harrison, Lauren Welch and Kaitlin Baudier.

After graduating, Welch became a Mackenzie Fellow at Audubon Arizona, where she helps organize trips through Phoenix nature preserves for local elementary school students. Her day-to-day looks a lot different now than in Panama, but she said the skills she learned doing field research and drafting the subsequent paper continue to play a role in her work today.

“One of the biggest things I took away from the trip was learning how to look around and appreciate everything,” she said. “I've always thought of myself as a scientific thinker, but actually going through the process of creating a hypothesis and testing it, then doing all of the background research to write up a paper, I’ve definitely applied what I've learned to everything I've done since.”

Welch’s project isn’t the only one to see publication. Previous trips have seen students pursue and publish research measuring tropical trees and plants, exploring the defense mechanisms of nonstinging bees and counting the number of animal species in main thoroughfares. 

Jon Harrison is a professor in the School of Life Sciences who has led the Panama program for the last five years. He said the tropical location and the autonomy of the course allows multifaceted research to thrive.

“Anyone interested in becoming a biologist should go to the tropics at least once, because it's very different from most of the U.S., Europe or Canada in terms of biodiversity,” said Harrison, who also co-authored Welch's research. “Given the biodiversity there and its importance to all the global cycles, it’s really valuable for our students to actually experience it on the ground.” 

Harrison estimates a handful of students from each summer program go on to pursue publication, a percentage of whom appear as the paper’s first author like Welch. But regardless of whether students take that next step, Harrison said all participants walk away with a different perspective on the natural world.  

“I don't think we've ever had a student come back without a much stronger appreciation for the tropics, for bugs, trees, and just the overall process of creating research,” he said. “To me that’s the most rewarding thing to see, because it’s this attitude of questioning and trying to come up with answers — it's more like an approach to life.” 

Written by Alisa Reznick

image title

ASU survey provides insights to Jewish community leadership

February 21, 2020

What do you do when you’ve been asked to work in service of a community of interest, but you’re not sure what interests the community? Or what size it is? Or what its core beliefs are? 

That has been the challenge facing Rich Kasper, president and CEO of the Jewish Community Foundation of Greater Phoenix, and Marty Haberer, president and CEO of the Jewish Federation of Greater Phoenix. And they were not alone.  

A comprehensive survey researching the behaviors, opinions, perspectives and preferences of the greater metropolitan Phoenix Jewish community has not been conducted for nearly two decades. The information gleaned back at the turn of the century is out of date, leaving Jewish community leaders to lead by instinct, anecdote and assumption. 

“The point is to be more efficient with the community’s resources and to be more effective,” Kasper said. “We want to know more about who we are, what we look like as a community, and what we want from each other."

Jewish community leadership found willing partners in Arizona State University President Michael Crow and Provost Mark Searle.  

“Our charter talks about taking responsibility for the well-being of the communities we serve,” Searle said. “We have done this kind of work for the African American community, the Latinx community and the Native American community, so this is what we do. We want to help in ways that are meaningful to those in the community and help them achieve their goals.”

Frank Jacobson, retired vice president of philanthropic services for Jewish Family and Children’s Service of Phoenix, was instrumental in moving the project forward. A seasoned and well-connected marketer and fundraiser, Jacobsen helped assemble an advisory group of interested leaders throughout the community to help define goals, objectives and areas of interest.

Haberer, Kasper and Jacobson all served on the 21-member advisory committee, joined by religious, educational, family and community leaders. ASU brought in professional research expertise that fielded the survey, crunched the numbers and analyzed the data, producing a final report.

Areas of study included: Jewish identity, religiosity and observance, participation in the Jewish community and in the broader community, Jewish upbringing, attitudes towards Israel and anti-Semitism, children and family, and service and care needs. 

Read the complete Jewish Community Study

What is now most important to advisory committee members is sharing the results from the survey and making sure it doesn’t sit on a shelf. The data provides a lot to dissect. 

“It needs to be out there and available for the use of whomever has a good and reasonable use for it,” Kasper said. “So, whether it’s our own organizations, or others that have an interest in serving the Jewish community — maybe for their own selfish reasons — that’s what we want, if it will strengthen our community in the process.” 

While different readers will focus on different parts of the survey, for Debbie Yunker Kail, the executive director of Hillel at ASU who also served on the advisory committee, the foundation of common understanding provided by the survey is a benefit. 

"In addition to gaining a deeper understanding of our community through this study, having an advisory committee was important because it brought many key community leaders together in collaboration for the advancement of our community,” Kail said. “Knowing that the leaders of our federation, foundation and so many other institutions will now have access to updated population information gives me great confidence that they can build the next years of their organizations off of sound data.”

Haberer said he is already thinking about how to take all of the new information that is now available and use it to help point the way forward for the federation.  

“This is a critical piece ... it is the quintessential compass for the Jewish community,” Haberer said. “It’s a gift to the community and it’s information that should be gleaned by those who are smart enough to use it as a roadmap. I think it will have a lot of impact in terms of where we invest our dollars.”

For Jacobson, who had been nudging this project forward for a few years before it came to fruition, it is an instrument for creating informed discussions.  

“What I’m interested in is the conversations that will come out of it from each of the areas of our committee chairs and their portfolios,” said Jacobson, reflecting on his role as administrative vice president of the board of directors of Congregation Or Tzion. “The membership committee may look at it one way, the fundraising committee a different  way, the special action committee may look at it another way and we may find ourselves using it in ways that none of us from the advisory committee even thought about. I think that’s how you bring life to this document.”