Think twice with 'brain training' programs


A human brain and skull are shown in an X-ray
|

Imagine never forgetting where you put your keys again. Or being able to weigh the odds at a blackjack table in seconds.

Having those kind of abilities sounds like something out of a Hollywood movie. In fact, the premise is one that has been explored in film many times before, including such recent movies as “Limitless” and “Lucy.”

In real life, we’ve yet to discover that magic little pill that will allow us to fully utilize our brain — but that hasn’t stopped some from trying.

So-called “brain training” programs offered by such websites as Lumosity and Cogmed have claimed that users can stave off dementia and even augment their intelligence. The training exercises consist of games that are geared toward improving an individual’s attention span and working memoryWorking memory is the ability to quickly recall information..

However, those companies have recently come under fire on charges of deceptive advertising — earlier in January, it was announced that Lumosity will pay $2 million to settle Federal Trade Commission charges — after several researchers in the field found that there was little to no evidence to support their claims of increased memory or intelligence.

A man poses for a portrait.
Arizona State University professor Zach ShipsteadZach Shipstead is an assistant professor in the School of Social and Behavioral Sciences, an academic unit of the New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences on Arizona State University’s West campus. (pictured left) agrees with them.

Along with colleagues, Shipstead conducted a study a few years ago on one of the games included in Lumosity’s suite of training exercises called the Dual N-Back task.

“Supposedly Dual N-Back improves working memory, improves intelligence, and we didn’t find any evidence of that, relative to a couple of different control groups,” he told HuffPost Live in a Jan. 7 Skype interview.

According to Shipstead, consumers should be cautious when it comes to the expanding market of brain-training programs because there’s just not enough evidence to show they actually work.

“There have been a lot of interesting small findings [in the field] but right now, the effects we’re producing are only large enough to be scientifically meaningful; not something that can be applied to real-world situations,” he said.

School of Social and Behavioral Sciences, West Valley campus, Health and medicine, Health care, New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences

More Health and medicine

 

A health care worker in a red shirt prepares a blood pressure monitor for an elderly woman in a navy-blue lace top. They are in a brightly lit room with medical supplies on a table.

BBC mini-documentary shines a light on community health workers in Arizona

When people think of health care professionals, what often comes to mind are doctors and nurses. In reality, there are more than 250 distinct professions in the field. This summer, a new…

Three nursing students wearing scrubs sit at a conference table listening to an instructor while a screen at the front of the room displays the words "Regina Fields Case Study."

ASU students evaluate agentic AI nurse assist's know-how

Regina Fields is a 35-year-old woman with an acute kidney injury. She’s short of breath, nauseous and having trouble urinating.The nurses taking care of Fields have questions about her condition, so…

Graphic illustration of a box labeled "excessive heat kit" with dotted lines leading to graphics depicting pets, a home, a thermometer and an air conditioner.

How to create a heat response plan for your family this summer

If your power goes out during a scorching summer day in the Valley, what will happen to your pets? Where will you sleep?The Health Observatory, a research initiative at Arizona State University, has…